"The government has relinquished control over the offshore areas of our industry. Norway was tough regarding oil companies from the start. You now have an almost embarrassingly large pension fund. The situation for Irish communities, however, is as in Ogoniland in Nigeria - oil is a curse,”
LETTER TO THE EDITOR
Expertise of Corrib Pipeline consultants in question
People need to understand the difference between 'production' pipeline and 'distribution' pipeline - a massive difference in operating pressure. By agreeing to a refinery 9km inland at Bellanaboy, the government is requiring Shell to construct an overland high-pressure 'production' pipeline.
Lorna Siggins states that RPS consultants, the company which Shell are hiring to assist in determining a new route for this pipeline, is described as a company which is "highly experienced in gas pipeline routing and environmental assessment", having worked for Bord Gáis on the 335km gas pipeline from Dublin to Galway-Limerick in 2002. There is a vast difference between a high-pressure raw gas 'production' pipeline and the domestic-use pressure of the Dublin to Galway-Limerick 'distribution' pipeline. To suggest that a company experienced in low-pressure distribution pipelines has the necessary expertise for planning a route for a high-pressure production pipeline is utterly ridiculous - like asking someone who builds garden sheds to be the architect for a new City Hall. No wonder the people of Erris have no faith in Shell's feeble pretentions to take account of the community's concerns.
The whole issue revolves around health and safety for the Erris community. A high-pressure gas pipeline at Carlsbad, New Mexico, operating at 46.6 Bar, ruptured due to internal corrosion on 19th August 2000. The blast and fire-ball killed a family of 12 who were camping more than 200 metres away. This pipeline was operating at less than one third of the proposed pressure that the Corrib pipeline could be operating at. Clearly the level of expertise of consultants is extremely important. The Carlsbad incident should be enough to convince any sane person that such a pipeline needs to be at least half a kilometre from any residence or public road.
Flagmount, Co. Clare.